Vote Rutherford
Beta
Back to Your Ballot

Constitutional Amendment #1

Proposes expanding non-bailable offenses for certain severe violent crimes.

Ballot Measure Details

How things work now:

Under the current constitution, everyone charged with a crime has a right to be released on bail before trial, except for people accused of a capital offense (a crime that can carry the death penalty).

What the amendment would do:

It would let a judge or magistrate deny bail before trial - keeping the person in jail until their case is resolved - for a specific list of serious charges: a capital offense, an act of terrorism, second-degree murder, aggravated rape of a child, aggravated rape, grave torture, or any offense for which a convicted person could not be released until serving at least 85% of the sentence. In those cases the judge or magistrate would have to state on the record the reasons for granting or denying bail.

A YES vote would allow judges to deny bail before trial for the listed serious offenses.
A NO vote would keep the current rule, under which bail can be denied only for capital offenses.

Supporters say:

It gives judges a tool to keep people accused of the most serious violent crimes from being released before trial, which they argue protects victims and public safety.

Opponents say:

It erodes the presumption of innocence by holding people who have not been convicted, and could keep more people in jail before trial, raising fairness and jail-population concerns.

Thank you to the LWV of Rutherford County for their explanation.

Find more information at TN SOS

Read full official ballot language

This amendment changes Article I, section 15 of the Tennessee Constitution by allowing a court to hold a defendant without bail before trial when that defendant is accused of: an offense punishable by the death penalty, an act of terrorism, second degree murder, aggravated rape of a child, aggravated rape, grave torture, or any crime for which a convicted person would be required to serve eighty-five percent of their sentence. This amendment requires courts to state on the record the reasons for their decision to grant or deny bail in those cases.

Choose your vote